Need advise on Toilet Flooring Rectification

[kil101 0]

Hi all,

My tiles started to suck air and water four years after my renovation (The warranty promised was 5 years). Problem was highlighted in February this year and finally, the ID company started to rectify it last Friday.

Initially when their sub con came to inspect my unit in Jun, he mentioned that the entire toilet flooring need to be changed. However, when they started work last Friday, it became only to do the dry area, wet area not affected. The company explained to me that only the "dry area" is affected. Since the there is a kerb between the "dry area" and the shower area, the shower area is not affected. 

However, it seems to be that be it dry area or wet area, it is still a similar layer of tiles. If there is water seepage into the tiles, doesn't it affect the other tiles as well. Similar, the hacking of one side of the tiles might also compromise the quality of the adjacent tiles. There are currently around 4-5 tiles on the shower area which is 25-75% hollow.

Below are my questions

1) Should the entire toilet flooring be changed?

2) How extensive should the renovation be (only the tiles and cement below are removed. Is there a need to do water proofing?)

3) If my ID firm is adamant that they are only changing the dry area tiles, what are the avenues I can seek?

I am not a pro when it comes to renovation. Hopefully someone can shed some light here for me.

I have attached some pictures of the flooring for your reference.

Cheers

Kil

[JohnHomeStylist 2]

Your toilet area is not really very big, so you can do the complete bathroom flooring work easily. If you will take out the loose tiles, then there are chances that you will face this same problem again. Go for complete bathroom flooring renovation, and you should have words with your bathroom contractor regrading warranty. 

[kil101 0]

Thank you John. They came and re-did the bathroom flooring already. But they left the glass panel area untouched and just cut the tiles around it. 

[bepgof 20]

Half-past-six job, however, every solution breeds new problem.

Smile, tomorrow could be worse.

But.....very often, if left to themselves, things tend to go from bad to worse.

Edited August 11, 2016 by bepgof